The best frosty makeup products balance high-shine shimmer with wearability — and not every icy shade gets that right. After comparing thirteen options, SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Waterproof Highlighter in Vanilla Frost earns the top spot for its buildable frosty sheen, waterproof formula, and flattering neutral base that works on most skin tones. Close behind, the ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan Palette is the strongest value for anyone building a full frosty eye look, and the NYX Buttermelt Highlighter in Butta Werk delivers the softest, most skin-like version of the trend. The main tradeoff in this category is between bold metallic frost and subtle glass-like glow, plus the staying-power gap between cream stick formulas and liquid or pressed options. Keep reading for the full ranking, including which budget picks punch above their price and which formulas to skip if you have texture-prone skin.
Get your wardrobe favorites delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
- Liquid and cream-gel formulas (SHEGLAM Glow Bloom, 2aN Pure Glass) outperformed pressed powders for that wet, frosty finish — the frosty look depends more on formula type than shade name.
- Wet n wild and L.A. COLORS proved frosty lipstick doesn’t require spending much, but both trade pigmentation density for shine, so they need layering over a liner for full coverage.
- Multi-stick versatility was the biggest differentiator: the wet n wild Snowy Skies multi-stick and NYX Jumbo stick work on eyes, cheeks, and lips, making them the smartest picks for minimalists.
- The L’Oreal Lumi Glotion landed lowest for true frost lovers — it reads as a natural glow enhancer rather than a frosty product, so match it to a soft-dewy goal, not an icy one.
- Silver-toned eye products (ColourPop Silver Lining palette, SHEGLAM Frost Bite jelly stick) flatter deeper and cooler skin tones best, while vanilla-based highlighters are the safer universal choice.
| SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Waterproof Highlighter, Vanilla Frost |  | Best Overall | Brand: SHEGLAM | Shade: Vanilla Frost | Type: Liquid Cream Highlighter | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze Stick for Eyeshadow, 01 Frost Bite |  | Best Multi-Use Stick | Shade: 01 Frost Bite | Texture: Lightweight hydrating jelly | Uses: Eyeshadow, highlighter, or shimmer lip balm | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstick, Dark Pink Frost |  | Best Value Frost Lip | Brand: wet n wild | Shade: Dark Pink Frost | Finish: Semi-matte, creamy | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Frosty Eyeshadow Stick – 01 Snow Cone |  | Best for Beginners | Brand: SHEGLAM | Product Type: Eyeshadow Stick | Shade: 01 Snow Cone | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| wet n wild Color Icon Cream Eyeliner Eyeshadow Multi-Stick – Snowy Skies |  | Best Pigmented Multi-Stick | Brand: wet n wild | Shade: Snowy Skies | Product Type: Multi-Stick (Eyeliner/Eyeshadow) | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Glow Highlighter – Vanilla Frost |  | Best Dual-Purpose Frost | Brand: SHEGLAM | Shade: Vanilla Frost | Finish: Shimmery | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan Eyeshadow Palette |  | Best Frosty Eye Palette | Brand: ColourPop | Shade range: Silver, grey, black, and white | Number of shades: 9 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter WH01 Frosty |  | Best Subtle Everyday Glow | Brand: 2aN | Shade: WH01 Frosty | Type: Powder highlighter | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| NYX Professional Makeup Buttermelt Highlighter, 15 U Butta Werk (Frosty Pink) |  | Best Long-Wear Frost | Brand: NYX Professional Makeup | Shade: 15 U Butta Werk (Frosty Pink) | Formula: Buildable powder highlighter | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Multi-Use Face Highlighter Stick – Vanilla Ice Cream |  | Best Beginner Frost Stick | Brand: NYX Professional Makeup | Product type: Face highlighter stick | Shade: Vanilla Ice Cream | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| White Moonlight Highlighter – Waterproof Diamond Glow Shimmer for Face & Body |  | Most Intense Frosty Shimmer | Shade: 01# White Moonlight (cool pearlescent shimmer) | Finish: Icy metallic / diamond shimmer | Formula: Cream, waterproof and sweat-proof | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| L’Oreal Paris True Match Lumi Glotion Natural Glow Enhancer, 903 Medium |  | Best for Everyday Wearability | Brand: L’Oreal Paris | Product Line: True Match Lumi Glotion | Shade: 903 Medium | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| L.A. COLORS Lipstick – Pink Frost (CML540) |  | Best Budget Frost Lip | Brand: L.A. COLORS | Shade: Pink Frost | Item Number: CML540 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| frosty makeup product | Shade | Brand | Finish | Cruelty-free |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Wate | Vanilla Frost | SHEGLAM | Shimmer / Dewy | — |
| SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze St | 01 Frost Bite | — | — | — |
| wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstic | Dark Pink Frost | wet n wild | Semi-matte, creamy | Yes |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Frosty Eye | 01 Snow Cone | SHEGLAM | Shimmer / Frosty Matte | Yes (Leaping Bunny Approved) |
| wet n wild Color Icon Cream Ey | Snowy Skies | wet n wild | Matte or Metallic | Yes |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Glow Highlighter | Vanilla Frost | SHEGLAM | Shimmery | Yes, Leaping Bunny Approved |
| ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan | — | ColourPop | — | Yes |
| 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter WH0 | WH01 Frosty | 2aN | Luminous, multidimensional | — |
| NYX Professional Makeup Butter | 15 U Butta Werk (Frosty Pink) | NYX Professional Makeup | — | Yes |
| NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo | Vanilla Ice Cream | NYX Professional Makeup | — | Yes (PETA certified) |
| White Moonlight Highlighter | 01# White Moonlight (cool pearlescent shimmer) | — | Icy metallic / diamond shimmer | — |
| L’Oreal Paris True Match Lumi | 903 Medium | L’Oreal Paris | Dewy, luminous | — |
| L.A. COLORS Lipstick | Pink Frost | L.A. COLORS | Frost | Yes |
More Details on Our Top Picks
SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Waterproof Highlighter, Vanilla Frost
This liquid cream highlighter earns the top spot because it delivers the frosty glow most buyers actually want: a dewy, lit-from-within shimmer that survives heat and sweat thanks to a waterproof formula. Compared with the SHEGLAM Lunar Glow Highlighter, the Glow Bloom’s liquid texture lets you sheer it out or build it up, which gives it more range than pressed-powder rivals. The hydrating base also means it sits better on dry skin than the 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter, though the tradeoff is real: the shimmer intensity runs bold, so anyone chasing a barely-there sheen will find it too much for daytime wear. For a frosty look with staying power, though, this pick makes the most sense.
Pros:- Waterproof and long-lasting formula outlasts powder rivals
- Liquid texture builds from medium to bold coverage
- Hydrating ingredients keep the shimmer from clinging to dry patches
- Multiple shades allow shade matching across skin tones
Cons:- Shimmer intensity is too bold for a subtle everyday look
- Liquid formula takes practice to blend before it sets
Best for: Buyers who want a high-shine, long-wearing frosty cheek glow that holds up through sweat, humidity, or long days
Not ideal for: Anyone wanting a subtle, office-appropriate sheen — the shimmer reads loud and layered looks get glittery fast
- Brand:SHEGLAM
- Shade:Vanilla Frost
- Type:Liquid Cream Highlighter
- Finish:Shimmer / Dewy
- Waterproof:Yes
- Long Lasting:Yes
- ASIN:B0BHQQSX91
Our verdict“This is the pick for anyone who wants their frosty glow to stay loud and locked in all day.”
SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze Stick for Eyeshadow, 01 Frost Bite
Where most frosty products do one job, this jelly glaze stick does three: eyeshadow, highlighter, and shimmer lip balm. Compared with the wet n wild Color Icon Multi-Stick, the Crystal Jelly leans wet and glossy rather than cream-to-powder matte, which makes it the better choice for that glazed, icy editorial look. The hydrating jelly texture blends with fingers in seconds, and the Leaping Bunny certification matters if cruelty-free sourcing drives your purchases. The tradeoff is longevity — a wet jelly finish moves more than a powder set shadow, and there’s no matte option for anyone who dislikes shine. As a lazy-day, one-stick routine builder, it stands out for convenience over precision.
Pros:- Triple-duty formula covers eyes, cheeks, and lips
- Lightweight jelly texture blends effortlessly with fingers
- Hydrating formula doubles as a lip treatment
- Leaping Bunny certified cruelty-free
Cons:- Wet finish fades and shifts faster than powder formulas
- No matte option — every use reads shiny
Best for: Minimalists and travelers who want one hydrating stick to handle eyes, cheeks, and lips with a wet frosty shine
Not ideal for: Matte makeup wearers or anyone who needs all-day crease-proof eye wear — the jelly finish stays tacky and shifts
- Shade:01 Frost Bite
- Texture:Lightweight hydrating jelly
- Uses:Eyeshadow, highlighter, or shimmer lip balm
- Certification:Leaping Bunny Certified cruelty-free
Our verdict“Buy this if you want a single glossy stick for a quick all-over frosty look, and skip it if matte is your default.”
wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstick, Dark Pink Frost
Most frosty products in this roundup are sticks and liquids for the face, so a classic frosted lipstick fills a gap — and this one does it with a genuinely conditioning formula. Aloe vera, vitamins A and E, macadamia nut oil, and hyaluronic microspheres mean it glides on silky instead of dragging like frosted lipsticks of decades past. Compared with the L.A. COLORS Pink Frost, this option offers a richer, buildable color payoff and better resistance to feathering and bleeding. The honest drawback is wear time: up to four hours means a midday reapply, especially after eating. Vegan and cruelty-free labeling sweetens the deal for budget-conscious buyers who still want skincare-adjacent ingredients in their lip color.
Pros:- Buildable color goes from soft wash to rich frost
- Silky glide with zero dragging on dry lips
- Hydrating ingredients condition lips throughout wear
- Resists caking, feathering, and bleeding
Cons:- Only four hours of listed wear time
- Frost finish can emphasize lip texture on chapped lips
Best for: Budget shoppers who want a hydrating, buildable frosted pink lip without splurging on luxury brands
Not ideal for: Anyone who refuses to reapply — four hours of wear means it disappears after lunch
- Brand:wet n wild
- Shade:Dark Pink Frost
- Finish:Semi-matte, creamy
- Wear time:Up to 4 hours
- Weight:0.13 oz
- Key ingredients:Aloe vera, vitamins A and E, macadamia nut oil, hyaluronic microspheres
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Vegan:Yes
Our verdict“This is the smart-budget frosted lip for buyers who don’t mind touching up between morning and evening.”
SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Frosty Eyeshadow Stick – 01 Snow Cone
Frosty eye looks intimidate people because loose glitter and powder shimmer are messy — this stick solves that. The creamy formula blends in seconds with a finger, then resists creasing, so there’s no brush skill required. Compared with the SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze Stick, the Lunar Jelly sets to a frosty matte-shimmer finish rather than staying wet, which makes it far more practical for everyday wear and hooded or oily lids. Against the ColourPop Silver Lining Palette, you trade shade variety for zero fallout and speed — one swipe, blend, done. The catch is restraint: the sparkle is delicate, so buyers chasing bold Y2K-level glitter will find it underpowered. For a first frosted eye, it’s the gentlest entry point here.
Pros:- Creamy formula blends in seconds with fingers
- Crease-resistant wear suits long days and oily lids
- No fallout or glitter mess unlike loose shimmer
- Leaping Bunny Approved cruelty-free
Cons:- Shimmer is subtle rather than statement-making
- Stick format makes precise cut-crease looks difficult
Best for: Makeup beginners or anyone short on time who wants a foolproof, no-fallout frosted eye in one swipe
Not ideal for: Glitter maximalists — the sparkle is subtle and won’t deliver a bold party-eye look
- Brand:SHEGLAM
- Product Type:Eyeshadow Stick
- Shade:01 Snow Cone
- Finish:Shimmer / Frosty Matte
- Formula:Cream stick
- Cruelty-Free:Yes (Leaping Bunny Approved)
- ASIN:B0HC5YS7TF
Our verdict“First frosty eyeshadow? This forgiving, fast stick is the easiest way in.”
wet n wild Color Icon Cream Eyeliner Eyeshadow Multi-Stick – Snowy Skies
This multi-stick differentiates itself through intensity: unlike the sheerer SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze Stick, the Color Icon delivers genuinely pigmented, buildable color across eyes, cheeks, and lips from a cream-to-powder base. The velvety finish sits somewhere between matte and metallic depending on the shade, so it can sharpen a frosty look with liner definition — something no highlighter in this lineup can do. Passion fruit seed oil, argan oil, and vitamin E keep the formula comfortable, and the vegan, cruelty-free credentials match pricier alternatives. The real weakness is oil control: on oily skin, cream formulas crease and fade without primer, whereas a powder option like the ColourPop palette holds steadier. Prime first and it’s a full-face tool in one pocket-sized stick.
Pros:- Intensely pigmented color that builds without patchiness
- Works as eyeliner, shadow, blush, and lip color
- Nourishing oils and vitamin E keep skin comfortable
- 13 shades give real variety beyond frost tones
Cons:- Creases and fades on oily skin without primer
- Multi-stick versatility means it masters no single category
Best for: Buyers who want saturated, buildable color for eyes, cheeks, and lips in a single portable stick — especially for defining and lining
Not ideal for: Oily-lid or oily-complexion buyers unwilling to use primer — the cream base creases and fades within hours
- Brand:wet n wild
- Shade:Snowy Skies
- Product Type:Multi-Stick (Eyeliner/Eyeshadow)
- Formula:Cream-to-Powder
- Finish:Matte or Metallic
- Key Ingredients:Virgin Passion Fruit Seed Oil, Argan Oil, Vitamin E
- Application Areas:Eyes, Cheeks, Lips
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
- Vegan:Yes
Our verdict“Grab this if you want one deeply pigmented stick that can define and color your whole face — just prime oily skin first.”
SHEGLAM Lunar Glow Highlighter – Vanilla Frost
This pick earns its spot by doing two jobs in one pan — it works as both a cheek highlighter and an eyeshadow, which immediately sets it apart from single-purpose options like the 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter. The multi-dimensional sheen shifts with lighting, so the frost effect looks alive rather than flat, and the creamy texture means fingers are enough for application on the go. Compared with the NYX Jumbo Stick, which offers stick convenience but a fixed placement style, this pressed format gives more control over intensity and placement. The tradeoff is shade variety: with only four options in the line, finding an exact skin-tone match takes more guesswork than brands with deeper ranges.
Pros:- Doubles as both highlighter and eyeshadow
- Multi-dimensional sheen that shifts in different lighting
- Creamy, silky texture blends easily with fingers or brush
- Leaping Bunny certified cruelty-free
Cons:- Only four shades available across the range
- Creamy formula may intensify texture on very oily skin
Best for: Minimalists who want one product for both eyes and cheekbones with a shimmery, light-shifting frost finish
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a wide shade range to match deeper or warmer skin tones — four shades limits options
- Brand:SHEGLAM
- Shade:Vanilla Frost
- Finish:Shimmery
- Formulation:Silky, creamy
- Use:Highlighter and eyeshadow
- Application:Fingers or brush
- Cruelty-Free:Yes, Leaping Bunny Approved
Our verdict“A smart two-in-one pick for anyone building a frosty look with fewer products.”
ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan Eyeshadow Palette
If your frosty look centers on the eyes, this is the most complete option in the lineup. Unlike the SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Eyeshadow Stick, which delivers one shade, this palette gives nine cool-toned shades across four finishes — matte, shimmer, metallic, and glitter — enough to build a full icy eye from base to inner-corner sparkle. The pressed powders are pigmented and blendable, which matters when you’re layering silver over grey without muddying the transition. The compact 0.3 oz format makes it travel-friendly compared with larger neutral palettes. The honest drawback: this is an unapologetically cool-toned range, so warm-complexion buyers may find the silver and grey family reads ashy rather than icy.
Pros:- Nine shades with matte, shimmer, metallic, and glitter finishes
- Highly pigmented and blendable pressed powders
- Compact 0.3 oz size travels well
- Vegan and cruelty-free
Cons:- Strictly cool-toned range that won’t flatter everyone
- Glitter shades can have more fallout than the mattes
Best for: Makeup wearers who want a complete silver-and-grey eye look with multiple finishes in one compact palette
Not ideal for: Warm undertones or anyone seeking neutral everyday shades — the cool range can look ashy
- Brand:ColourPop
- Shade range:Silver, grey, black, and white
- Number of shades:9
- Finishes:Matte, shimmer, metallic, and glitter
- Formula:Pressed powder
- Weight:0.3 oz
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-free:Yes
Our verdict“The clear choice for building a full frosty eye look rather than accenting with a single shade.”
2aN Pure Glass Highlighter WH01 Frosty
Not every frosty look needs to be loud, and this is where the 2aN Pure Glass earns its place. Its fine micro-pearls create a soft, natural glow — a quieter effect than the high-impact shimmer of the NYX Buttermelt Highlighter, which is built for maximum wattage. The white and silver pigments deliver a genuine frost tone with a multidimensional finish, making it a strong pick for office-friendly winter makeup or anyone easing into the trend. Compared with the SHEGLAM Lunar Glow, this is strictly a face product, so it sacrifices the two-in-one versatility in exchange for a more diffused, skin-like result. Buyers wanting that glass-skin sheen rather than visible sparkle will find this the better fit.
Pros:- Soft, natural-looking glow rather than heavy glitter
- Fine micro-pearls diffuse evenly on skin
- True white-silver frost tone with multidimensional finish
- Powder format is easy to layer over foundation
Cons:- Too subtle for dramatic or event looks
- Single-shade purchase limits styling options
Best for: Buyers who want a wearable, low-key frosted sheen for daily or professional settings
Not ideal for: Anyone chasing a bold, blinding highlight — the micro-pearl effect is deliberately understated
- Brand:2aN
- Shade:WH01 Frosty
- Type:Powder highlighter
- Finish:Luminous, multidimensional
- Key pigments:White and silver glitters
- Effect:Soft micro-pearl glow
Our verdict“The best pick for a restrained, skin-like frost that reads polished instead of theatrical.”
NYX Professional Makeup Buttermelt Highlighter, 15 U Butta Werk (Frosty Pink)
This option stands out for staying power: a transfer- and fade-resistant formula advertised to last up to 12 hours without fallout, which no other powder in this lineup claims. Where the 2aN Pure Glass keeps things soft, Butta Werk is buildable to high impact, and the frosty pink tint gives cooler skin a flattering warmth that pure white-silver shades can’t. The mango, shea, and almond butter infusion translates to a smoother, less powdery application — a real benefit for drier skin types that find traditional highlighters cakey. The buttery base is also the tradeoff: on oily skin, buildable formulas can emphasize shine by midday, so the 12-hour wear may vary with your skin type. Frost purists may also find the pink shift less icy than true silver options.
Pros:- Advertised 12-hour transfer- and fade-resistant wear
- Buildable from soft glow to high-impact shimmer
- Mango, shea, and almond butters smooth application on dry skin
- Cruelty-free and vegan
Cons:- Butter-rich formula may not hold up as well on oily skin
- Frosty pink tint is warmer than true white-silver frost
Best for: Long days and events where highlight needs to survive without touch-ups, especially on drier skin
Not ideal for: Very oily skin types who find butter-rich formulas slide or look greasy by afternoon
- Brand:NYX Professional Makeup
- Shade:15 U Butta Werk (Frosty Pink)
- Formula:Buildable powder highlighter
- Wear time:Up to 12 hours
- Key ingredients:Mango butter, shea butter, almond butter
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Vegan:Yes
Our verdict“The strongest choice when longevity matters more than an icy-pure white finish.”
NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Multi-Use Face Highlighter Stick – Vanilla Ice Cream
For anyone new to frosted makeup, this stick removes nearly every barrier to entry. The twist-up format needs no sharpener and no brush — swipe on cheeks or nose, blend with fingers, done. That makes it far more forgiving than powder options like the 2aN Pure Glass, which rewards precise brush placement, and faster than the SHEGLAM Lunar Glow pan for on-the-go touch-ups. The weightless, buildable formula with jojoba oil means a light first pass reads subtle, so mistakes are easy to fix — a genuine advantage while learning placement. The tradeoff: stick formulas deliver a softer, more diffused frost than pressed powders, so maximum blinding shine isn’t the goal here. And with six shades in the line but one per purchase, building a multi-shade routine gets expensive.
Pros:- Twist-up stick needs no sharpener or brushes
- Weightless, buildable formula suits light-handed beginners
- Jojoba oil keeps application smooth and even
- PETA certified cruelty-free with 6 shades in the range
Cons:- One shade per purchase despite six in the line
- Softer payoff than powder highlighters for intense looks
Best for: Beginners who want a foolproof, no-tools application and a buildable introduction to frosted highlighting
Not ideal for: Anyone wanting maximum metallic impact — the creamy stick finish is softer than pressed powders
- Brand:NYX Professional Makeup
- Product type:Face highlighter stick
- Shade:Vanilla Ice Cream
- Available shades:6 pearl pigment infused shades
- Applicator:Twist-up stick
- Formula:Blendable, infused with Jojoba Oil
- Use areas:Cheeks, nose, face
- Cruelty-free:Yes (PETA certified)
Our verdict“The easiest on-ramp to the frost trend for beginners and busy routines alike.”
White Moonlight Highlighter – Waterproof Diamond Glow Shimmer for Face & Body
If the goal is a true icy, diamond-level frost rather than a soft glow, this is the strongest option in the lineup. The cream formula’s light-reflective pigments push toward a metallic white shimmer that reads unmistakably frosty — where the L’Oreal True Match Lumi Glotion keeps things natural and dewy, this one commits to the full winterized effect. The waterproof, sweat-resistant base means the shimmer survives long days on collarbones and shoulders without patching, and the creamy texture avoids settling into pores. It also layers well: a sheer pass gives glass-skin sheen, while a second pass delivers drama.
The tradeoff is shade temperature. That cool pearlescent white can clash with warm or olive undertones, where a champagne option like NYX Buttermelt in Butta Werk would flatter more. Buyers wanting subtlety should look elsewhere.
Pros:- Waterproof and sweat-resistant enough for body application and long wear
- Creamy texture blends without cakiness or emphasizing pores
- Multi-use on cheekbones, nose, eyes, collarbones, and shoulders
- Buildable from sheer glass-skin sheen to intense metallic shine
Cons:- Cool white shade can look too stark or ashy on warm undertones
- Less subtle than liquid glotions — hard to dial down for everyday wear
Best for: Anyone building a bold frosty or glass-skin look who wants high-impact shimmer that survives sweat and humidity on both face and body
Not ideal for: Warm or olive-toned skin — the pure white cool shimmer can read ashy rather than luminous
- Shade:01# White Moonlight (cool pearlescent shimmer)
- Finish:Icy metallic / diamond shimmer
- Formula:Cream, waterproof and sweat-proof
- Available Shades:01 White Moonlight, 02 Champagne Gold, 03 Pink Glow
- Application Areas:Face and body (cheekbones, nose, eyes, collarbones, shoulders)
- Packaging:Mirrored compact case
- Skin Tone Compatibility:All skin tones
Our verdict“Pick this if maximum icy shimmer is the whole point; skip it if your undertone runs warm or you prefer a barely-there glow.”
L’Oreal Paris True Match Lumi Glotion Natural Glow Enhancer, 903 Medium
Not every frosty makeup fan wants a full-on ice queen look daily, and that’s exactly the gap this fills. The Lumi Glotion translates the frosty trend into something office-appropriate: a hydrating liquid glow powered by glycerin and shea butter that moisturizes while it illuminates. Compared with the White Moonlight Highlighter, which builds toward metallic intensity, this stays in natural, sun-kissed territory — closer to skin than shimmer. Its flexibility is the real selling point: wear it alone as a tinted moisturizer hybrid, under foundation, or dabbed on cheekbones as a subtle highlight. Five shades mean most buyers can find a plausible match.
The catch is the dewy finish itself. On oily skin, that sheen can tip from glowy to greasy by midday, and anyone expecting coverage will find this is an enhancer, not a foundation. For dry or normal skin, though, it’s the most wearable frost-adjacent pick here.
Pros:- Glycerin and shea butter deliver all-day hydration alongside the glow
- Extremely versatile — alone, under foundation, mixed with moisturizer, or as a highlighter
- Natural dewy finish reads as skin, not shimmer
- Five shades across the tone spectrum
Cons:- Too dewy for oily skin types without blotting or setting
- Provides minimal coverage for those wanting a foundation effect
Best for: Dry or normal skin types who want a subtle, frost-inspired glow that doubles as daily hydration and can be worn alone or layered under makeup
Not ideal for: Oily skin — the dewy finish can look greasy — and anyone expecting foundation-level coverage
- Brand:L’Oreal Paris
- Product Line:True Match Lumi Glotion
- Shade:903 Medium
- Size:1.35 fl oz
- Key Ingredients:Glycerin, Shea Butter
- Available Shades:5
- Use Areas:Face and body
- Finish:Dewy, luminous
Our verdict“The most low-maintenance way into the frosty-glow trend — ideal for dry skin and minimalists, wrong for anyone wanting shimmer or coverage.”
L.A. COLORS Lipstick – Pink Frost (CML540)
A frosty face needs a matching lip, and this is the roundup’s cheapest ticket there. The contour tip is the standout detail — it hugs the lip line for precise application without a liner, which matters more with frost finishes since edges show clearly. Vitamin E and aloe keep the creamy formula from feeling like the drying frosted lipsticks of decades past, and the color payoff is genuinely vibrant for the price. Compared with the wet n wild Silk Finish in Dark Pink Frost, this skews pinker and brighter rather than deep, making it the better pick for a playful ’90s-throwback look while wet n wild suits richer, moodier frost.
The honest limitation: frost lips are polarizing, and no formula innovation changes that. If mirrored lips aren’t your thing, this won’t convert you — and the hydration, while decent, won’t replace a balm on chapped lips.
Pros:- Contour tip allows precise application without a lip liner
- Vitamin E and aloe keep the creamy formula comfortable
- Vibrant color that holds up through wear
- Cruelty-free and inexpensive enough to try the trend risk-free
Cons:- Frost finish is a strong, dated aesthetic that won’t appeal to everyone
- Hydrating but not a substitute for lip balm on dry or chapped lips
Best for: Anyone completing a frosty look on a budget who wants a precise, hydrating pink frost lip without buying a liner
Not ideal for: Anyone who dislikes mirrored or frosted lip finishes — the shine is the whole product, not an option
- Brand:L.A. COLORS
- Shade:Pink Frost
- Item Number:CML540
- Finish:Frost
- Key Ingredients:Vitamin E, Aloe Vera
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
Our verdict“A low-risk, precise way to get the frosted-lip look — buy it for fun, not as an everyday nude.”
How We Picked
I judged every product against the same four criteria, because “frosty” means different things across the makeup aisle. First, frost quality: does the finish actually read as cool, icy shimmer rather than warm glitter or generic glow? Second, formula performance — blendability, buildability, and how the product wears over four to eight hours, since frosty finishes tend to emphasize texture and fade patchily when the base formula is weak. Third, versatility: whether the product works across multiple skin tones and can be layered into a full look. Fourth, value relative to format, since a $4 lipstick and a full 9-pan palette can’t be compared on price alone — only on whether the buyer gets a complete frosty result.
The ranking favors products that deliver a true frosty payoff with the fewest caveats. That’s why waterproof liquid highlighters rank above standard pressed ones, and why multi-use sticks score well despite smaller shade ranges. Products were demoted when their frost effect depended on heavy layering, when the shade pulled warm instead of icy, or when the formula demanded primer-and-setting-spray prep just to function.
| frosty makeup product | Cruelty-free |
|---|---|
| SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Wate | — |
| SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze St | — |
| wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstic | Yes |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Jelly Frosty Eye | Yes (Leaping Bunny Approved) |
| wet n wild Color Icon Cream Ey | Yes |
| SHEGLAM Lunar Glow Highlighter | Yes, Leaping Bunny Approved |
| ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan | Yes |
| 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter WH0 | — |
| NYX Professional Makeup Butter | Yes |
| NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo | Yes (PETA certified) |
| White Moonlight Highlighter | — |
| L’Oreal Paris True Match Lumi | — |
| L.A. COLORS Lipstick | Yes |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Frosty Makeup Products
Frosty makeup is one of the trickiest trends to shop for because the same shade name can mean wildly different results depending on formula, undertone, and where you place it. Before picking from the lineup above, here are the broader factors that separate a flattering icy glow from a chalky, dated finish.Frost vs. Glitter vs. Glow — Know Which Look You’re Buying
These three finishes get used interchangeably on packaging, but they look completely different on skin. True frost is a fine, dense, cool-toned shimmer that reflects light evenly — think liquid highlighters like the SHEGLAM Glow Bloom. Glitter contains visible particles that can look festive on eyes but chunky on cheeks, which is where budget body shimmer products often go wrong. Glow is diffuse and skin-like, closer to what the L’Oreal Lumi Glotion produces. The most common shopping mistake is buying a glow product expecting frost, or vice versa. Check whether the product description says “shimmer,” “metallic,” or “natural radiance” — those words map to different results. If your goal is the bold Y2K icy look, lean metallic or shimmer; if you want a wearable winter glow, natural radiance products will serve you better.
Undertone Matching Matters More in Frosty Shades
Frosty finishes amplify undertone clashes because cool shimmer sits directly on the skin’s surface. Silver and icy white shades flatter cool, olive, and deeper skin tones beautifully but can turn ashy on very warm or fair-medium complexions. Vanilla and champagne-frost shades — like the Vanilla Frost highlighters in this lineup — are the most forgiving across skin tones because their slight warmth keeps the frost from looking chalky. Frosty pink lipsticks follow the same rule: they brighten neutral-to-cool complexions but can wash out very warm ones. A useful test is to hold the product near a piece of silver jewelry versus gold — if silver flatters you, true frost shades will too. Buyers with warm undertones aren’t excluded from the trend; they just need frost with a golden or peach base rather than pure white shimmer.
Formula Type Determines Wear Time and Skin-Texture Behavior
The biggest predictor of satisfaction isn’t brand — it’s format. Liquid and waterproof gel formulas melt into skin, last through humidity, and resist the patchy fading that plagues frosty finishes. Cream and jelly sticks blend beautifully and layer over other products, but they can shift on oily skin without setting. Pressed powders and palettes give the most control and buildability, yet powder shimmer collects in fine lines and pores, so texture-prone skin should apply them with a damp sponge and a light hand. If you have oily or combination skin, prioritize waterproof claims and cream-to-powder finishes. Dry skin types actually benefit from frosty cream formulas, since the emollient base adds sheen rather than clinging to dry patches the way powder shimmer does.
Multi-Use Products Save Money but Limit Precision
Multi-sticks like the wet n wild Snowy Skies and NYX Jumbo stick are appealing because one product covers eyes, cheeks, and sometimes lips. That economy is real — a three-product frosty look collapses into one $6 purchase. The tradeoff is that a formula engineered to work everywhere is rarely the best at any single job: eye-safe shimmer usually has finer particles than ideal for cheek highlight, and lip-safe pigments can be less intense than a dedicated lipstick. If frosty makeup is an occasional look for you, multi-sticks are the smarter buy. If it’s a signature style, dedicated products — a real frosty lipstick, a true eye palette, a targeted highlighter — will always outperform the all-in-one approach. Decide which camp you’re in before choosing between the stick and palette options in this roundup.
Avoiding the Dated Frosty Look
The difference between modern frost and a 1990s frosted flashback comes down to placement and density. The dated look happens when frost is applied flat across the whole lid or lip with no dimension. Contemporary application concentrates frosty shimmer at the inner eye corner, cheekbone peak, or center of the lip, paired with matte or satin areas for contrast. Pairing one of these frosty highlighters with a matte blush is the easiest way to make the trend read current. Another common mistake is skipping base prep — frosty shimmer magnifies everything underneath, including uneven foundation edges. Finally, resist using frosty products on every feature at once; one or two icy accents per look keeps the effect editorial rather than costume-like.
When It’s Worth Paying More
This category has genuinely strong drugstore options, so premium spending should be targeted, not automatic. It’s worth paying more for better base ingredients — the NYX Buttermelt and 2aN Pure Glass formulas blend more seamlessly and wear longer than their cheapest competitors, which matters most on mature or textured skin where budget shimmer can look gritty. It’s also worth paying up for a full palette like ColourPop’s if you’ll actually use multiple shades, since single frosty shadows bought separately cost more per use. Conversely, frosty lipstick is one category where the budget picks (wet n wild, L.A. COLORS) perform close to premium level, because the shine effect is largely formula-driven rather than pigment-driven. Spend where the formula touches textured skin; save where it’s a sheer shine layer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do frosty highlighters work on mature or textured skin, or will they emphasize fine lines?
They can work, but formula choice does most of the heavy lifting. Liquid and cream-gel highlighters — like the SHEGLAM Glow Bloom or 2aN Pure Glass — sit flush with skin and reflect light evenly, which softens rather than magnifies texture. Powder and pressed-shimmer formulas are riskier because individual shimmer particles settle into fine lines and enlarged pores. If you prefer a powder, apply it with a damp sponge rather than a brush and keep it to the highest point of the cheekbone, away from the under-eye area. The NYX Buttermelt is the most texture-friendly pick in this lineup specifically because its buttery base diffuses rather than deposits particles. Placement matters as much as product: high and outward, never directly over lines.
What’s the difference between the SHEGLAM Glow Bloom liquid highlighter and the SHEGLAM Lunar Glow powder in Vanilla Frost?
Both share the Vanilla Frost shade, but they’re built for opposite situations. The Glow Bloom is a liquid, waterproof formula that creates a wet, glassy sheen and layers well under or over foundation — it’s the stronger pick for dry skin and long days since it won’t fade or lift. The Lunar Glow is a pressed highlighter, which gives more control over intensity and is easier to target precisely on cheekbones or the brow bone. Powder also travels better in a makeup bag and applies faster with a brush. Choose the liquid if you want maximum frost impact and longevity; choose the powder if you like adjusting intensity through the day or have oilier skin that breaks down liquid products. Some users keep both, using liquid as a base and powder to intensify the peak.
Are frosty lipsticks like the wet n wild Dark Pink Frost and L.A. COLORS Pink Frost flattering on everyone?
Frosty lipstick is the most undertone-sensitive product in this category. Cool and neutral complexions tend to wear pink frost well because the blue-ish shimmer brightens teeth and matches the skin’s natural cast. Warm undertones may find the same shades pull slightly lavender or washed out, which is fixable by layering the frost over a warmer matte lip liner. Both budget options are also sheerer than their swatches suggest, so lining underneath adds both depth and longevity. Application technique helps too: pressing the lipstick on rather than swiping keeps the shimmer even instead of streaky. If you’re frost-curious but cautious, these inexpensive lipsticks are actually the lowest-risk way to test the trend before committing to a premium version.
Can I use the jelly eyeshadow sticks and multi-sticks on sensitive eyes or over contact lenses?
Jelly and cream eyeshadow formulas are generally friendlier than loose glitters because there’s no fallout risk — the shimmer stays suspended in the base rather than flaking onto the eye. The SHEGLAM Crystal Jelly Glaze and Lunar Jelly sticks are designed as eye-safe products, which matters because not all shimmer products in this category are; multi-sticks will typically state whether they’re ophthalmologist-tested or eye-safe on the packaging, and that labeling is worth checking. For contact lens wearers, cream formulas applied with a fingertip and blended away from the lash line reduce transfer. The real risk with any cream eye product is migration into the eye by end of day, so a light translucent setting powder over the lid helps lock it down. If your eyes water easily, waterproof claims — like those on the Glow Bloom — are a better signal of staying power than brand reputation.
Is the L’Oreal Lumi Glotion actually frosty, or is it more of an everyday glow product?
Honestly, it’s the latter, and that’s why it ranks toward the bottom of a specifically frosty lineup despite being a solid product on its own merits. The Lumi Glotion produces a soft, lit-from-within sheen closer to a tinted illuminator than an icy highlighter — there’s no concentrated shimmer payoff, just diffuse luminosity. That makes it a poor match if your goal is the bold, metallic frosty look shown in most trend imagery. However, it’s an excellent choice if you want a subtle winter-appropriate glow you can wear to the office, and its larger bottle and mixable format make it workable as a body or all-over-face product where true frost would be too much. Think of it as the frosty trend’s toned-down sibling: same family, different intensity. Buy it for glow, not for frost.
Conclusion
The right pick depends entirely on how bold you want your frost. For best overall, the SHEGLAM Glow Bloom Liquid Waterproof Highlighter in Vanilla Frost delivers the most convincing icy finish with the fewest caveats — waterproof, buildable, and flattering across skin tones. The best value is the ColourPop Silver Lining 9-Pan Palette if you want a complete frosty eye look, or the wet n wild Dark Pink Frost lipstick if you’re testing the trend at minimum cost. For a premium finish, the 2aN Pure Glass Highlighter offers the most refined, glass-like take on frost in the lineup. Beginners should start with the NYX Jumbo Multi-Use Stick in Vanilla Ice Cream — one forgiving, blendable product covers eyes and cheeks without technique demands. For specific needs: minimalists get the most from the wet n wild Snowy Skies multi-stick, mature or textured skin is best served by the NYX Buttermelt, body shimmer calls for the White Moonlight Diamond Glow, and anyone wanting a wearable daytime glow rather than full frost should pick the L’Oreal Lumi Glotion. Whichever direction you choose, pair one or two frosty accents with matte elements — that contrast is what keeps the look modern.
Evergreen bestsellers Picks
bestsellers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
