TL;DR
Get your wardrobe favorites delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Jimmy Kimmel said Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson’s elimination from Dancing with the Stars was an outrage, then joked about taking legal action in a backstage interview. The pair left after a Super Bowl-themed salsa earned 22 out of 40 points; the account does not provide the vote totals or explain how judges’ scores and viewer votes determined the result.
Jimmy Kimmel criticized viewers after his friend and Dancing with the Stars contestant Guillermo Rodriguez was eliminated with professional partner Witney Carson, following the show’s Tuesday-night Super Bowl-themed episode. On Jimmy Kimmel Live, Kimmel called the result an outrage and joked with the pair backstage about taking legal action; the elimination ended their run in the competition.
Kimmel argued that the pair had built substantial online attention, displaying figures he said showed their routine received 719,000 YouTube views the previous week. He compared that with 231,000 views for Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson, whom he described as the next-highest viewed pair. Those figures refer to views, not votes, and do not establish how viewers voted or how online attention translated into the show’s results.
For their Super Bowl-themed performance, Rodriguez and Carson danced a salsa to music by Bad Bunny. The judges awarded them 22 out of 40 points: Carrie Ann Inaba gave them 6, Derek Hough 5, Joe Buck 6 and Bruno Tonioli 5. Kimmel called it Rodriguez’s highest score to date and said he had again been in the bottom two before viewers failed to keep the pair in the competition.
Speaking to Kimmel from backstage, Rodriguez agreed with the host’s joking suggestion that they take legal action, while Carson also said she was on board. Kimmel praised Carson’s choreography and asked what she would miss about training Rodriguez. She called him a sweetheart and joked that Kimmel could take him back. Rodriguez said he had set out to lose weight and had done so; Kimmel responded with a joke about Carson being pregnant. The exchange was presented as banter, not a stated legal plan.
Dancing with the Stars · Week Five
Why Did Jimmy Kimmel Slam Voters After Guillermo’s DWTS Elimination?
Kimmel called Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson’s exit an outrage after their Super Bowl-themed salsa scored 22 out of 40. He pointed to online views and a strong score, but the vote totals and the show’s full vote calculation were not reported.
What happened
A strong score did not save the pair
Guillermo Rodriguez, known as Jimmy Kimmel’s sidekick, competed with professional partner Witney Carson on Season 35. After their salsa on the Super Bowl-themed episode, the pair was eliminated.
Super Bowl salsa
Rodriguez and Carson danced a salsa to music by Bad Bunny during the Tuesday-night episode.
Kimmel objected
On Jimmy Kimmel Live, he called the result an outrage and joked backstage about taking legal action.
Their run ended
The elimination stood. No complaint or legal case by Rodriguez or Carson was reported.
The judges’ numbers
22 points across four scores
Kimmel described the result as Rodriguez’s highest score to date. The account reports each judge’s score for the salsa.
Each bar is scaled to a 10-point judge score. The reported points add up to 22.
Online attention vs. voting
The figures Kimmel cited measure views
Kimmel compared YouTube views for clips from the prior week. These figures suggest reach and interest; they do not reveal how many eligible votes each contestant received.
| Pair | Reported views | What the figure tells us |
|---|---|---|
| Guillermo Rodriguez & Witney Carson | 719,000 | Views of their previous-week routine, as cited by Kimmel |
| Harry Shum Jr. & Jenna Johnson | 231,000 | Comparison figure Kimmel described as the next highest |
What is missing: The account does not report vote totals, a full voting breakdown, or precisely how judges’ scores and audience votes combined in this result.
How the story unfolded
From dance-floor exit to late-night punchline
They perform
Rodriguez and Carson dance a Super Bowl-themed salsa to Bad Bunny.
Scores are given
The judges award 22 points out of a possible 40.
They are eliminated
The pair leaves the competition after the episode’s result.
Kimmel responds
He criticizes viewers, then jokes backstage about legal action with the pair.
In their words
Outrage, affection and backstage banter
The legal-action exchange was presented as a joke. The comments do not describe an announced legal plan.
“This is an outrage. Will you accept the results or take legal action?”
Jimmy Kimmel · joking backstage
“Last week, Guillermo and Witney had more than triple the YouTube views of their closest opponent.”
Jimmy Kimmel · on online attention
“He’s such a sweetheart. He’s so loved by everyone.”
Witney Carson · about Rodriguez
“I said I was going to lose weight and I did lose weight.”
Guillermo Rodriguez · backstage
What comes next
Dedication Night is scheduled for Tuesday
The remaining contestants are set to perform on the next episode of Dancing with the Stars.
Tuesday · 8 p.m. ET/PT
The episode is scheduled to air on ABC and Disney+.
Dedication Night
The announced theme for the next episode.
Hulu next day
A next-day stream is scheduled on Hulu.
Key questions
What the account confirms—and what it doesn’t
Why did Kimmel criticize voters?
He was upset that viewers did not keep Rodriguez and Carson in the competition. He cited online attention and their judges’ score; the account does not establish why viewers voted as they did.
What score did the pair receive?
They earned 22 out of 40: 6 from Carrie Ann Inaba, 5 from Derek Hough, 6 from Joe Buck and 5 from Bruno Tonioli.
Did anyone take legal action?
No legal action is reported. The backstage suggestion was comedic banter, and the pair played along.
Do YouTube views show how people voted?
No. The cited 719,000 and 231,000 figures are video views. The account does not connect them to voting totals.
Online Attention Versus Show Results
The elimination highlights a gap between the online popularity Kimmel cited and the outcome of a live competition. YouTube views indicate that people watched clips; they do not show how many eligible votes a contestant received, whether those viewers voted, or how the program combines audience votes with judges’ scores. The available figures therefore support Kimmel’s point about attention, but not a conclusion that voting was unfair.
The episode also shows how the result became part of Kimmel’s late-night show, where his personal support for Rodriguez shaped a humorous response to the exit. His remarks drew attention to the result beyond the competition broadcast, while the backstage exchange gave the eliminated pair a chance to respond. The central confirmed outcome remains straightforward: Rodriguez and Carson were eliminated, despite receiving their reported best score of the season.
Dancing with the Stars salsa dance costumes
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How The Week Five Result Unfolded
Rodriguez, known as Kimmel’s sidekick on Jimmy Kimmel Live, competed on Season 35 of Dancing with the Stars with Carson as his professional partner. According to Kimmel’s account, they reached Week 5 and had repeatedly depended on viewers to avoid elimination. The Super Bowl-themed episode included their salsa performance and judges’ scores before the pair’s departure was announced.
Kimmel also played clips of news programs in the United States and Canada supporting Rodriguez. That coverage, like the YouTube figures, indicates public interest but does not provide a count of votes. The show’s next episode is scheduled to air Tuesday at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+, with a next-day stream on Hulu. Its announced theme is Dedication Night.
“This is an outrage. Will you accept the results or take legal action?”
— Jimmy Kimmel
Vote Totals Remain Unreported
The account of the episode does not include viewer vote totals, the full voting breakdown, or a detailed explanation of how audience votes and judges’ scores were combined for the elimination. It is not clear whether the YouTube figures Kimmel cited had any connection to voting, and they cannot be treated as evidence of vote counts. Kimmel’s criticism was his reaction to the result, not proof that the voting process was improper.
The reported backstage comments about legal action were part of a comedic exchange. Neither the interview nor the account reports that Rodriguez or Carson filed a complaint or intended to pursue a case. The precise circumstances of the vote that sent them home remain unavailable in the details provided.
Dedication Night Follows Tuesday
Rodriguez and Carson’s competition run is over, and the remaining contestants are set to perform on the next episode, whose announced theme is Dedication Night. The program is scheduled for Tuesday at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+, with streaming on Hulu the following day. No further action by Rodriguez, Carson or the show over Kimmel’s comments has been reported.
For viewers seeking a fuller explanation of the elimination, the key missing information is the show’s vote breakdown and the way it factored into the result. Until those details are made public, Kimmel’s comments and the online-view totals offer context for the reaction, but not a full account of why the pair was eliminated.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
Key Questions
Why did Jimmy Kimmel criticize voters?
Kimmel was upset that viewers did not keep Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson in the competition. He pointed to the pair’s reported online attention and their judges’ score, then called the elimination an outrage. The available account does not establish why viewers voted as they did.
What score did Guillermo and Witney receive?
The pair received 22 out of 40 points for their Super Bowl-themed salsa. The four scores reported were 6 from Carrie Ann Inaba, 5 from Derek Hough, 6 from Joe Buck and 5 from Bruno Tonioli.
Did Kimmel, Guillermo or Witney actually take legal action?
No legal action is reported. Kimmel raised the idea in a backstage exchange, and Rodriguez and Carson played along; the comments were presented as jokes, not an announced legal plan.
Do the YouTube views show how viewers voted?
No. Kimmel cited 719,000 YouTube views for the pair’s previous-week performance and compared that with 231,000 for another couple. Those are video-view figures, not vote totals, and the account does not connect them to the show’s voting results.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
